The research came from a well respected non profit organisation FREOPP, the foundation for research on equal opportunity. I think it’s fair to say that many readers did not agree with their findings, but what are the facts.
The modern Portugal health care system was founded in 1979 with the establishment of the Portuguese National Health Service. Bear in mind that this was just five years after the 1974 revolution and building a proper public health service came with a lot of challenges. The UK NHS was started in 1948 by the then health minister Aneurin Bevan, and despite a thirty year start on Portugal the NHS still attracts major problems and criticism. People’s expectations of a free health service are high but difficult to meet.
In an emergency
Portugal’s health service is seen at its best in an emergency. I know from personal experience that if you call for an ambulance you are unlikely to wait more than ten minutes, though that does depend on your location. Our grandson went to the aid of an elderly lady who took a fall in Oxford last week and the ambulance took four hours to reach her. She had a fractured hip. I have never heard of such a delay in Portugal.
National emergency institute (INEM)
The INEM (that’s the yellow ambulances) paramedics are well trained and efficient and the emergency departments at all the hospitals I have had any dealings with are fast and good. These ambulances are kept locally on standby, usually at the local fire station, one reason they can arrive so quickly. In addition, the INEM service have ‘flying doctors’, that’s the small yellow car you may see rushing to an accident or emergency. They carry a doctor and a nurse who can immediately start appropriate treatment over and above what a paramedic can perform. They also have helicopters stationed within a few minutes of any appropriate emergency, INEM are very well equipped and well trained. Local firemen also have ambulances to deal with less serious needs. In an emergency, INEM offers an outstanding (free) service.
One person within a group of people I know well was told on her return to the UK “you would never have received such good treatment here". Most doctors and nurses I have had any dealings with seem to default to English dealing with any foreigner, and in most cases its very good English. That’s in the Algarve and it may not be the case further north.
Waiting times in outpatients
One of the major problems seems to be with the hospitals outpatient’s department. This is partly a cultural problem, by default most Portuguese people will go straight to the hospital outpatients for any health issue.
The government has tried, partially successfully, to address this by opening health centres in most towns and cities. In theory this is where you should find your ‘family doctor’ but the serious shortage of doctors means that you might wait years to get a doctor assigned to you. Meanwhile there will be a doctor on service, but there is a high demand to see them. The nurses are very good and seem capable of dealing with fairly minor issue with little delay. The reality is that if you go directly to the hospital you will see a doctor, albeit with a delay of two or three hours. In recent years the patient will be assessed quickly by a triage nurse to determine the urgency of treatment needed but it will still be a long wait unless it’s urgent.
Despite the governments best efforts, the lack of family doctors, what the English call a GP, is a major problem. If it’s a routine or minor illness you may be waiting a long time to get treatment, even to get an appointment. If you do manage to get a family doctor, matters can move a little quicker though the lack of specialists for non-urgent treatment is still a problem.
Public v Private
In order to meet the needs of fast treatment and care, the private sector has developed with impressive speed. They have their own emergency departments where you can see a doctor 24/7. As medical insurance is substantially less expensive in Portugal than many European countries, the private health care system seems to be a very viable alternative to the public sector. Its fast, accessible, and high quality. The cost of seeing a doctor or specialist, if you don’t have private health insurance, seems to be around €70 for an up to thirty-minute consultation. The private sector can offer all the services the public sector can offer, and with high quality of treatment.
To take an overview, if you need emergency care the public health system will take very good and very fast care of you, and the treatment etc will be free. Most countries have bilateral agreements with the Portuguese health system. As a foreign resident or visitor, the emergency health care is outstanding.
Shop around for Private health insurance
There is an extensive chain of private local clinics everywhere who can deal with minor ailments quickly. Although there is a cost, this is by far the best way to find a family doctor.
For day to day non urgent health care, the private sector can offer all you need. Shop around for health insurance, basic cover can be obtained for around 25 Euros a month while you are young, around €50 a month for someone in their early fifties. Look for a company that has a direct agreement with private hospitals, so they settle the bill direct.
Resident in Portugal for 50 years, publishing and writing about Portugal since 1977. Privileged to have seen, firsthand, Portugal progress from a dictatorship (1974) into a stable democracy.
Just utter nonsense.Which would explain why your refused to publish my damning indictment of experiencing the Portuguese healthcare system first hand.
My mother died here in a routine operation.
I had to have the same operation twice because the first was botched.
I know someone that was sent home with paracetamol with chest pains.His wife's family managed to get him to a police hospital in Spain where they discovered he had a bacterial heart infection which untreated would have led to his death.
Nothing in Portugal is what it seems.
I called the GNR last thursday night only to be told they were too busy to be able to attend.
This is a country bordering on a failed state where laws are not applied equally to all.
From planning and noise regulations that are overlooked to so many other issues.
That makes it uninvestable.
By james from Algarve on 26 Sep 2021, 08:55
The article is not objective. There is too much on the experience of individuals rather than a substantial analysis of large numbers of people who have experience of the system. For what it’s worth, my experience is that the Algarve is lacking in facilities for more sophisticated procedures. The private system is very money orientated. I lived in the north in Braga before Algarve and their equivalent of the UK national health system was very good.
By Russell from Algarve on 28 Sep 2021, 12:27
The Portuguese health system compares well with the uk . The article says if you go to a hospital you have to wait 2/3 hours ....this is quite good in the uk Wait target is 4 hours and that’s only reached about 80% of the time . Similar to Portugal seeing a GP is difficult a person can wait days or weeks for a routine appointment...at least ina Portuguese health centre youcan see a GP even if you have to wait or come back later . Finally Portugal seems to treat serious deceases like cancer or heart problems just as well or based on conversations I have had better than the uk . No doubt it could be better ...but don’t look to the uk for better service
By Graham Burgess from Algarve on 28 Sep 2021, 16:06
My original opinion of the Portuguese NHS, it was brilliant where I first lived, and needed to see a GP. I was seen within an hour or so. I was referred to the emergency department at the local hospital for tests, there I was seen within half an hour. Fortunatley there appeared to be nothing seriously wrong. I returned to my GP the same day and he sent me for further tests. The end of the week I saw him again, simple prescription, no more problems. Where I now live though there has been no GP for nearly two years. I can go to another health centre at 3am Saturday, or Sunday or on a bank holiday, in the hope that I might get to see a GP. I'm 73 years old and don't drive. I would have to rely on someone else to take me!
By Steve Cook from Beiras on 28 Sep 2021, 19:09
Us and our friends have found the Portuguese medical care to be absolutely fantastic! I was therefore really surprised by some comments, because in every way it is better (faster, better care, more up-to-date) than France which we lived in the last 13 years, and the UK before that.
By David Bloch from Algarve on 01 Oct 2021, 14:06
James, you are right - Portugal is bordering a failed state at many levels. It is only interested in marketing non quality tourism, selling over priced real estate to wealthy foreigners and keeping the local population in dire poverty. It is no wonder that Portuguese die earlier and earlier.
By K from Other on 06 Oct 2021, 10:28